Wednesday, October 16, 2019

LET'S NOT STIFLE RESEARCH


Linda and her Mom
Borrego Springs, about 2005

A long time ago I wrote a blog about the question of whether or not a gene can be subject to patent.   


 On the face of it the concept is absurd; maybe one could patent a method to isolate the gene or to somehow mess with it, but the gene itself is found in billions of cells in every human being on earth.  No way can you patent that.

Well, it appears that the issue has evolved significantly since then.  In 2013 the Supreme Court ruled that genes are not subject to patent.  Now it seems that a bipartisan group of congress persons want to reverse that ruling.  From my viewpoint, this a big mistake, in that it inevitably would increase the cost of gene sequencing aimed at dealing with cancer.  In fact, the question arose initially with regard to the well-known BRCA genes.

The rational for reversing the SCUS ruling is not laid out in the link given below.  I wish it were; I would like to understand the reasoning behind such a prima facia bit of nonsense.

But, anyway, we don’t need to worry – nothing is going to happen in Washington any time soon.

No comments:

Post a Comment